The leading mid-range hotel in Key West — 120 rooms at the Historic Seaport with a balcony on every single room (most with partial ocean view), an ocean-view pool, full spa, and the solid Hyatt Centric formula applied to the American subtropics. World of Hyatt points redeemable. CNT Readers' Choice 2025.
Why We Chose It
Hyatt Centric Key West is the top-recommended mid-range hotel on the island — a 120-room property at the Historic Seaport that delivers the Hyatt Centric formula: boutique-hotel personality with full-brand reliability. Every single room has a balcony, most with at least a partial ocean view; breezy white linens and light wood accents with teal penny tile set a clean tropical tone. The ocean-view pool and the swing at the end of the dock are standout features. On-site restaurant Four Flamingos is solid; the Marquesa Patio above it is the spot for sunset photos. World of Hyatt points redeemable. Appears on both CNT (Readers' Choice 2024, 2025) and T+L best hotels lists.
What Stands Out
- Every room has a balcony — most with partial ocean view
- Best mid-range consistency in Key West — Hyatt Centric formula
- Historic Seaport location — prime position near Duval Street
- Ocean-view pool and the iconic dock swing
- World of Hyatt points redeemable · CNT Readers' Choice 2024, 2025