Roosters wandering the tables, a reggae band in the corner, and the lobster Benedict that made this Bahama Village courtyard famous.
Why It Belongs on the List
Blue Heaven is the experience that people plan their Key West trip around. Located in a quirky open-air courtyard in Bahama Village — where Hemingway reportedly once refereed boxing matches — it serves the finest brunch in Key West. The lobster Benedict, banana pancakes, and mile-high key lime pie are the dishes to order. Arrive early for brunch — waits of 1–2 hours are common. Dinner reservations available.
What Stands Out
- Roosters and chickens wander freely — genuinely
- Lobster Benedict and banana pancakes are the moves
- Mile-high key lime pie with meringue
- Former boxing ring — Hemingway reportedly refereed here
- Arrive early for brunch — 1-2hr waits are normal