Widely considered the best fine dining restaurant in Key West. A small, elegant room in Old Town with an inventive New American menu. Consistently voted the top romantic restaurant in Key West.
Why It Belongs on the List
Café Marquesa is the place locals recommend when someone asks for the best meal in Key West — a small, refined dining room inside the Marquesa Hotel with an inventive New American menu that changes with the season. Chef Susan Ferry has built a reputation for precision and creativity. Only 50 seats — reservations are essential.
What Stands Out
- Voted the best fine dining in Key West
- Only 50 seats — intimate and refined
- New American menu with strong local seafood focus
- Top romantic restaurant — multiple local awards
- Reservations essential