A nine-room inn overlooking Menemsha harbor — gardens, a strong restaurant, and one of the most atmospheric settings on the island.
Why We Chose It
Beach Plum Inn sits on a hillside above Menemsha Harbour — nine rooms and cottages in a beautifully tended garden property with a fire pit, hot tub, and the Beach Plum restaurant (one of the island's most acclaimed for its local seafood and New England cooking). The setting is extraordinary: rolling gardens with water views, the quiet of up-island Chilmark all around, and Menemsha Beach and Larsen's Fish Market a short walk below. The most romantically positioned inn on the island.
What Stands Out
- Nine rooms and cottages
- Menemsha Harbor garden views
- Acclaimed Beach Plum restaurant
- Fire pit and hot tub
- Short walk to Menemsha Beach
- Most romantic up-island inn
- Local seafood focus