A quietly distinguished hotel on St. Barths — a beautifully designed 45-room boutique resort on the calm waters of Marigot Bay away from the island's main social circuit, with a rooftop bar with exceptional lagoon views, direct lagoon swimming, and the most peaceful atmosphere of any hotel on the island.
Why We Chose It
Le Barthélemy opened in 2016 on a quiet stretch of Marigot Bay on the northeastern coast and quickly established itself as the most underrated hotel on the island — 45 rooms with a warm, residential design sensibility that feels different from the high-gloss luxury of Cheval Blanc or Rosewood. The calm lagoon beach is ideal for swimming. The rooftop bar Aux Amis has become the best sundowner spot among those who know the island well. The restaurant serves good contemporary French-Caribbean food. The spa is excellent. The relative distance from Gustavia's social scene means Le Barthélemy attracts a quieter, more discerning crowd.
What Stands Out
- Most underrated hotel on St. Barths — beautifully designed, less crowded
- Aux Amis rooftop bar — the best sundowner spot for island insiders
- Direct access to calm Marigot Bay lagoon swimming
- Contemporary French-Caribbean design with residential warmth
- Quieter alternative to the main resort circuit