Refined Caribbean fine dining in a restored 18th-century plantation building on the North Shore — the island's most ambitious kitchen and one of its most atmospheric settings.
Why It Belongs on the List
Old Stone Farmhouse occupies a restored 18th-century stone plantation building on the North Shore near Mahogany Run, with an interior of exposed stone walls, wood beams, and a historic atmosphere that sets it apart from every other restaurant on St. Thomas. The kitchen emphasizes local seafood, steaks cooked to order, and a rotating tasting menu that has made it a favorite among the island's repeat visitors. The setting is genuinely special — a proper destination restaurant, worth the drive from Charlotte Amalie or the east end. Reservations essential.
What Stands Out
- 18th-century stone plantation building — island's most atmospheric setting
- Island's most ambitious fine-dining kitchen
- Rotating tasting menu and local seafood focus
- North Shore location — destination dining
- Reservations essential