Marathon's working waterfront fish house. Pull up to the outdoor counter and order the lobster Reuben — the legendary sandwich of the Keys.
Why It Belongs on the List
Keys Fisheries is a genuine working fish market that happens to serve food — you order at a window and eat at picnic tables on the dock with pelicans and tarpon circling below. The lobster Reuben — a full lobster tail on rye with Swiss and sauerkraut — is worth the drive from anywhere in the Keys.
What Stands Out
- Genuine working fish market
- Lobster Reuben — the iconic sandwich of the Middle Keys
- Order at a window
- eat on the dock
- Pelicans and tarpon begging below your table
- Marathon waterfront atmosphere